- Top Tier
- Pro Period : 1920 - 1934
- 317 matches - 40 goals - / assists
- Defensive-Midfielder
- 14 Trophies/3 Individual Awards
- Top Tier
- Pro Period : 1918 - 1937
- / matches - / goals - / assists
- Center-Back/Right-Back
- 14 Trophies/5 Individual Awards
- Top Tier
- Pro Period : 1916 - 1939
- 329 matches - 223 goals - 159 assists
- Second Striker/Striker/Right-Winger
- 35 Trophies/4 Individual Awards
#4
Luis Alberto Suárez Díaz "El Pistolero"
- Top Tier
- Pro Period : 2004 -
- 926 matches - 553 goals - 297 assists
- Striker/Right-Winger/Left-Winger
- 23 Trophies/14 Individual Awards
#5
Juan Alberto Schiaffino "El dios de futbol"
- Highest Legends
- Pro Period : 1946 - 1963
- 470 matches - 159 goals - 258 assists
- Attacking-Midfielder/Central-Midfielder/Second Striker
- 25 Trophies/5 Individual Awards
#6
José Emilio Santamaría Iglesias
- Highest Legends
- Pro Period : 1948 - 1966
- 373+ matches - 2+ goals - / assists
- Libero/Center-Back
- 21 Trophies/1 Individual Award
#7
Obdulio Jacinto Muiñoz Varela "El Negro Jefe"
- Really Good Legends
- Pro Period : 1938 - 1955
- / matches - / goals - / assists
- Defensive-Midfielder/Center-Back
- 24 Trophies/3 Individual Awards
#8
Enzo Francescoli Uriarte "El Príncipe"
- Really Good Legends
- Pro Period : 1980 - 1997
- 625 matches - 216 goals - / assists
- Second Striker/Striker/Attacking-Midfielder
- 12 Trophies/21 Individual Awards
#9
Acldies Edgardo Ghiggia Pereyra "El Héroe del Maracaná"
- Really Good Legends
- Pro Period : 1945 - 1967
- 514 matches - 51 goals - / assists
- Right-Winger
- 5 Trophies/4 Individual Awards
#10
Atilio Ceferino García Pérez "Bigote"
- Good Legends
- Pro Period : 1931 - 1953
- 375 matches - 349 goals - / assists
- Striker
- 24 Trophies/10 Individual Awards